Waiting for the F Train

Currently  I am in the South of France on a writing retreat. I went running on the mountain today and it was so beautiful that  it made me thing of a not so beautiful moment back home, waiting for the F train in NYC.

Waiting on the platform, a disheveled man stood next to me. The next minute he fell in the tracks. I screamed. I weight 110 ten pounds and knew I couldn’t get him out and since nobody was helping him, I ran upstairs as fast as I could and told the MTA people behind the glass. Then I ran back downstairs.

When I arrived back at the scene, two men had pulled him out. His forehead was bleeding and he was clearly drunk and confused. The two men and I kept telling  him that it would be all right, but that he needed to go to the hospital.

“No, no! I don’t have to go to the hospital. Don’t make me go.” he slurred over and over.

“But your head is bleeding and you’re not well.” I tell him. “You just fell in the tracks.”

But, he isn’t coherent. He is upset. He says he doesn’t want to go. I keep hoping the police or ambulance will get here soon to look at him and help him, but they don’t.

The man walks up the stairs, his face covered in blood , and there is nothing I can do to stop him.

My nerves are raw from the fact that a man had just almost fallen to his death. If a train had been coming he’d be up shit’s creek.

One of the guys who helped him out walks up to me. “Crazy, huh?” he says.

“Yes.” I say. “That poor guy.”

“I know.” he says.

Then a guy walks down the stairs. By coincidence, he knows the man I’m standing with and says to him, “Hey man, what’s up?”

“Dude, it’s crazy. This poor guy just fell in the tracks. It was surreal.” he says.

Without a blink of an eye the guy says, “Fuck. Does that mean the train’s delayed?”

At that very moment I hate this guy.

But, I’m wise enough now to know that anything I hate is in me, too, or else I wouldn’t be able to recognize it.  I also see myself in him. New York does that to you. It tightens you and dehumanizes you without you even knowing it. Not all the time. But, sometimes. How does trying to catch the next train strip us of our humanity? Are we sensory overloaded? Are we afraid to feel because we see extreme wealth and poverty rub up against each other every day?

I don’t know, but a strange thing happens. I go from despising this stranger, to having compassion for him, and by extension, for myself.

The paramedics arrive looking for the person in trouble.

“You missed him.” I say.

Then the F train comes speeding up, the doors open, and I step on.

6 Responses to “Waiting for the F Train”


  1. 1 Jenni July 20, 2012 at 1:44 pm

    I had a moment like that headed to penn station from Chelsea, when a saw a blind man bump in to someone  then get confused and almost ended up in traffic .. I over heard the man he bumped into say to the lady next to him ” he did that on purpose” as he rushed through the crowd headed to the station. I was just so blown away, and just froze. The blind man got his bearings and got back on the sidewalk and the other guy just rushed off.

    • 2 racheldardenbennett July 20, 2012 at 2:42 pm

      Jenni, I know. It’s wild how people can literally turn off their humanity. Where the compassion comes in, I realize, is that that guy you witnessed who said that about the blind person clearly hasn’t any compassion for himself. I realize that often when I rush, it brings aggression. They are intimately linked. The question is: Can we move mindfully and stay relaxed in New York? Do you think it’s possible?

  2. 3 Hillary July 20, 2012 at 2:15 pm

    “anything I hate is in me, too, or else I wouldn’t be able to recognize it”… This phrase really struck me and made me stop and think about my own reactions to people. This is so true. It’s amazing to recognize this in the moment though, and shift from hatred to compassion. This is a beautiful piece on New York.

    • 4 racheldardenbennett July 20, 2012 at 2:39 pm

      Hillary, I know. It’s a powerful thing to take responsibility for all the parts of ourselves. Compassion is like working a muscle. I find that when I try to relax my body – literally soften and feel where I am in space, I can make that shift to compassion, rather than search for it. Thanks for responding!

      • 5 ashia July 23, 2012 at 6:59 pm

        Rachel, I too resonated on that line… been thinking about it a lot recently. Your writing is powerful and insightful and wise. Thank you for sharing it.

      • 6 racheldardenbennett July 23, 2012 at 9:33 pm

        Ashia, It is a pretty big trip when we realize that all things are inside us. I think that when we repress our dark side, the less-than perfect side, we lose touch with our authenticity. I’m beginning to realize that true compassion springs from knowing the limitations within myself and learning to love and forgive myself, and by extension, others. A life’s work! So great to get your comment, thank you!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s





Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 49 other followers

%d bloggers like this: